Introduction
By Paul Sandberg, Project Director
In project-based manufacturing, accurately matching revenue and expenses within the same accounting period is crucial for financial accuracy. The percent of completion (POC) method provides a structured way to recognize revenue and expenses in alignment with a project’s progress. This article explores how a fictitious manufacturing company, Proactive Custom Manufacturing (PCM), can implement the POC method, account for upfront deposits, and manage revenue recognition effectively over long-term projects.
The Challenges of Revenue Recognition in Manufacturing
PCM specializes in producing high-end custom components for industrial clients. Their projects often span six months or more, with payments structured as upfront deposits, progress payments, and final payments. If PCM were to recognize revenue only when payments were received, its financial statements would be misleading—showing spikes in revenue during payment months and underreporting during production months.
By applying the POC method, PCM can:
1. Accurately match revenue and expenses.
2. Provide a realistic view of financial performance.
3. Comply with accounting standards such as GAAP and IFRS.
Example cash basis Income Statement:
Month 1: receive $50,000 deposit
Month 2: expense $250,000
Month 3: expense $250,000, invoice $200,000 progress payment
Month 4: invoice final $750,000 invoice
Month 1 | Month 2 | Month 3 | Month 4 | |
Income | $50,000 | $200,000 | $750,000 | |
Expense | $250,000 | $250,000 | ||
Gross Profit | $50,000 | ($250,000) | ($50,000) | $750,000 |
Step 1: Accounting for Upfront Deposits
When PCM receives an upfront deposit from a client, it should not immediately record it as revenue. Instead, the deposit should be placed into a Revenue Billed Not Earned account, which is a liability on the balance sheet. This ensures that revenue is recognized in proportion to the project’s completion.
Journal Entry for Upfront Deposit:
Cash (Asset) | $50,000 |
Revenue Billed Not Earned (Liability) | $50,000 |
This entry reflects that while cash has been received, the work has not yet been performed.
Step 2: Recognizing Revenue Using the Percent of Completion Method
PCM determines project completion percentage by comparing actual costs incurred to total estimated costs. If a project is estimated to cost $500,000 and PCM has incurred $250,000 in costs, the project is 50% complete.
If the total contract value is $1,000,000, the revenue to recognize is: 50% of $1,000,000 = $500,000
PCM must move a portion of the Revenue Billed Not Earned into a recognized revenue account.
Journal Entry for Recognized Revenue:
Revenue Billed Not Earned (Liability) | $500,000 |
Revenue (Income) | $500,000 |
This aligns revenue recognition with project progress.
Step 3: Accounting for Work Performed but Not Yet Billed
If PCM has completed 50% of a project but has only billed 40% of the contract, there is an additional 10% of revenue that has been earned but not yet invoiced. This is recorded in a Revenue Earned Not Billed account (an asset on the balance sheet), ensuring that revenue is recognized even if billing lags behind work progress.
Journal Entry for Revenue Earned But Not Yet Billed:
Revenue Earned Not Billed (Asset) | $100,000 |
Revenue (Income) | $100,000 |
This entry ensures that PCM recognizes revenue in line with project progress rather than billing milestones.
Step 4: Managing Progress Payments and Final Payments
Throughout the project, PCM may issue progress invoices based on the contract terms. When a progress payment is received, PCM records it as follows:
Journal Entry for Progress Payment:
Cash (Asset) | $200,000 |
Accounts Receivable (Asset) | $200,000 |
When the project reaches completion and the final invoice is sent, PCM adjusts the remaining balances, moving any unbilled revenue into accounts receivable and ensuring that all revenue has been recognized.
Step 5: Closing the Project
Once PCM completes the project and receives the final payment, the balance sheet should reflect that:
- Revenue Billed Not Earned has been fully transferred to revenue.
- Revenue Earned Not Billed has been moved to accounts receivable and subsequently collected.
- Expenses have been fully accounted for and match the recognized revenue proportionally.
Example true Accrual Percent of Completion Income Statement
Month 1 | Month 2 | Month 3 | Month 4 | |
Income | $500,000 | $500,000 | ||
Expense | $250,000 | $250,000 | ||
Gross Profit | $250,000 | $250,000 |
Conclusion
The percent of completion method provides PCM with a robust framework to align revenue recognition with project progress. By properly handling upfront deposits, progress payments, and earned-but-unbilled revenue, PCM ensures that financial reporting reflects the true state of operations. This method not only enhances financial transparency but also supports better decision-making for project managers and stakeholders.